
New York Sends Hochul a Bill to Ban Red No. 3 Food Dye and Make Companies Disclose Self-Affirmed GRAS Ingredients
New York lawmakers delivered a bill to Gov. Kathy Hochul on Nov. 13 that would ban the food dye Red No. 3, potassium bromate and propylparaben, and require companies to report ingredients they have declared safe without notifying the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
A New York bill that would ban the synthetic food dye Red No. 3 and two other additives went to Gov. Kathy Hochul on Nov. 13, according to the state Legislature’s records. The Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act would also make New York the first state to require food companies to report ingredients they have self-affirmed as “generally recognized as safe” (GRAS), according to the law firm Keller and Heckman.
TLDR
- The bill would ban food containing FD&C Red No. 3, potassium bromate or propylparaben, according to the bill text.
- Companies would have to report self-affirmed GRAS ingredients to the state, which would post the reports in a public database. Independently owned businesses with 100 or fewer employees would be exempt.
- Keller and Heckman says Hochul has 10 days, not counting Sundays, to sign or veto the bill, or it becomes law without her signature.
- Food industry groups have urged a veto, citing costs. In Texas, a new bill would extend the state’s school meal ban on dyes such as Red 40 and Yellow 5.
What the Bill Would Ban
The bill, S1239F in the Senate and A1556G in the Assembly, adds Red No. 3, a synthetic color, to a short list of banned food substances. The other two are potassium bromate, used in flour, and propylparaben, a preservative.
Under the bill text, the ban starts one year after that section takes effect, and the act itself takes effect one year after it becomes law. Stores could keep selling products they already hold until the printed date runs out, for up to three years. Keller and Heckman described the effective date as 180 days after enactment. The bill text delivered to the governor says one year.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has already revoked the authorization for Red No. 3 in food, with a food deadline of Jan. 15, 2027. Potassium bromate and propylparaben have no federal ban.
What GRAS Reporting Would Require
Under federal law, a company can decide on its own that an ingredient is GRAS and use it without telling FDA. The New York bill would require companies to file a report for such ingredients with the state Department of Agriculture and Markets before selling food that contains them.
The state would post the reports in a searchable public database. Trade secrets could be redacted, but the safety data could not. Ingredients that already received an FDA “no questions” letter, and ingredients in common use before 1958, would be exempt, along with independently owned businesses of 100 or fewer employees.
FDA has proposed its own rule to require GRAS notices for all substances claimed as GRAS. Comments on that proposal close Dec. 9.
Industry Pushback
Food industry groups have asked Hochul to veto the bill. The Consumer Brands Association said in April that it duplicates federal oversight and would raise grocery costs. The association and other groups cited estimates of $21 million in state costs over three years and price increases of up to 12%, without naming who produced those figures. The Center for Science in the Public Interest, which backs the bill, notes that companies can now use such ingredients without notifying FDA.
Why It Matters
States are moving on additives while federal rules are still being written. In Texas, where bill prefiling for the 2027 session began Nov. 9, HB 518 would extend the state’s current school meal ban on additives such as brominated vegetable oil, Red 40 and Yellow 5 to all meals schools sell during the school day, with exceptions for contracted restaurants and vending machines, Keller and Heckman reported. A signature in Albany would put the first state GRAS disclosure system on the books ahead of any final federal rule.
Sources: New York Assembly, A1556G bill text and actions; New York Senate, S1239F; Keller and Heckman, The Daily Intake (Nov. 16, 2026); Consumer Brands Association (April 29, 2026); Center for Science in the Public Interest fact sheet.
