Tagatose Maker Bonumose Petitioned FDA to Let Its Rare Sugar Count as Dietary Fiber

Bonumose has petitioned the Food and Drug Administration to widen its definition of dietary fiber so that D-tagatose, a low-calorie rare sugar, could be listed as fiber on the Nutrition Facts label. FDA denied a similar Bonumose request in 2021.

Bonumose, a Virginia company that makes the rare sugar D-tagatose, has asked the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to let food companies declare tagatose as dietary fiber on the Nutrition Facts label. The citizen petition was received by FDA on Oct. 23 and posted to the public docket on Oct. 30, and the law firm Keller and Heckman reported it on its Daily Intake blog on Nov. 18.

TLDR

  • FDA defines dietary fiber as non-digestible carbohydrates with 3 or more monomeric units, plus some others it has reviewed.
  • Tagatose is a single-unit sugar, so it falls outside that definition.
  • Bonumose asks FDA to drop the size cutoff and to allow fiber labeling for tagatose before any rulemaking.
  • FDA denied a similar Bonumose petition in 2021.

What Bonumose Is Asking For

FDA’s rule at 21 CFR 101.9(c)(6)(i) defines dietary fiber as non-digestible soluble and insoluble carbohydrates with 3 or more monomeric units, plus lignin and certain isolated or synthetic carbohydrates that FDA has found to have beneficial physiological effects. D-tagatose is largely a non-digestible monosaccharide, meaning it has a single unit.

The petition makes two requests, according to the Daily Intake. First, FDA would amend the definition to include non-digestible carbohydrates with fewer than three units. Second, it would allow D-tagatose to be declared as dietary fiber based on its claimed physiological benefits. Bonumose also asks FDA to use enforcement discretion so companies could label tagatose as fiber before a rule is final.

A Second Attempt

FDA denied a similar Bonumose petition in June 2021. In that response, the agency found the three-unit cutoff consistent with international scientific consensus. Bonumose now argues the cutoff is a policy choice, not a scientific requirement, and that non-digestible carbohydrates can have beneficial effects regardless of size. The petition cites evidence of health effects for D-tagatose. The Daily Intake post does not list them, and the petition text could not be retrieved for this story.

Tagatose on the Label So Far

This is not Bonumose’s first labeling fight. FDA denied its 2022 request to keep tagatose out of the Added Sugars line, and in 2024 a court found that denial arbitrary and capricious, AgFunderNews reported. In a November 2025 letter, FDA said it would use enforcement discretion to let companies exclude D-tagatose from the Added Sugars and Total Sugars declarations and count it at 1.5 calories per gram, compared with 4 for regular sugar. AgFunderNews reported that Bonumose’s backers include Hershey and that ASR Group distributes its tagatose.

Why It Matters

Rare sugars such as tagatose and allulose are moving into products that cut sugar, and their labeling is still being settled. A fiber declaration would let tagatose appear in a different line of the label from sugar. The docket shows no FDA response so far and no comment deadline.


Sources: The Daily Intake, Keller and Heckman (Nov. 18, 2026); Bonumose citizen petition, docket FDA-2026-P-13333; FDA response to Bonumose (June 15, 2021); AgFunderNews (Elaine Watson, April 10, 2026).